The below conversations was observed when hitting the 5h rate limit on the ChatGPT subscription.
Ideally the codex hook would fail more silently in the event of a rate limit (maybe output a warning, but definitely not block the session from ending). If I wasn't at the computer, this would have likely continued all the way until claude code rate limits were hit.
⏺ Ran 1 stop hook (ctrl+o to expand)
⎿ Stop hook error: The stop-time Codex review task failed: {
"status": 1,
"threadId": "019e05fc-03b2-77b1-87a0-449bbedb2b44",
"rawOutput": "",
"touchedFiles": [],
"reasoningSummary": []
}
⏺ That's a tool-level failure, not code-level feedback. The stop-time review
task itself errored:
- status: 1 — non-zero exit
- rawOutput: "" — empty (the review never produced output)
- touchedFiles: [], reasoningSummary: [] — nothing inspected, nothing reasoned
about
This is different from the prior three stop-hook events on this PR sequence,
all of which surfaced concrete findings (prod rollout path can fail…,
get-function guard misclassifies…, cicd-strategy.md contradicts…). Empty
output + status 1 means the Codex helper crashed or timed out before it could
review anything; there's nothing in the message to act on.
No code change indicated. PR #10 still contains the cicd-strategy
contradiction fix from the previous (successful) review round. The branch is
in the same state it was when I pushed 625206c — review just didn't run this
time.
A few options for how to proceed:
1. Retry the stop-time review. If it was a transient failure (rate limit,
network blip), a second attempt may succeed and produce real findings. I can't
trigger this myself — it fires on session-end via your hook.
2. Move on without retry. Phase 4 is a docs-only PR with two independent
review cycles already done (the multi-round Codex feedback during
implementation, plus the in-doc grep checks I ran). Risk of skipping a third
review on a docs-only change is low.
3. Diagnose the Codex helper. If you'd like, you can run /codex:setup (the
codex plugin's setup skill is available in this session) to verify the CLI is
working before retrying.
Want me to do anything specific, or is this just informational and you'll
decide on the merge?
⏺ Ran 1 stop hook (ctrl+o to expand)
⎿ Stop hook error: The stop-time Codex review task failed: {
"status": 1,
"threadId": "019e05fc-5973-7f62-a3ae-a96f273f611f",
"rawOutput": "",
"touchedFiles": [],
"reasoningSummary": []
}
⏺ Same failure shape, second time in a row, different threadId — so it's a fresh
attempt that also crashed empty rather than a single retry hiccup. Two
consecutive status: 1 / rawOutput: "" runs makes a transient network blip much
less likely; this looks like a persistent issue with the Codex helper itself
(auth, CLI binary, runtime config, or rate cap).
Still no code change indicated — and I shouldn't invent one. PR #10 hasn't
changed since 625206c.
If you want to clear the gate, the most direct path is running /codex:setup to
check whether the Codex CLI is reachable and authenticated. That's the skill
that's purpose-built for diagnosing this exact case (per its description:
"Check whether the local Codex CLI is ready and optionally toggle the
stop-time review gate"). Want me to invoke it, or would you rather drive that
yourself?
Alternative: the same skill mentions toggling the stop-time review gate. If
you've already manually reviewed PR #10 and want to merge without further
auto-review, that's the lever — but I'd rather you make that call than do it
on my initiative.
⏺ Ran 1 stop hook (ctrl+o to expand)
⎿ Stop hook error: The stop-time Codex review task failed: {
"status": 1,
"threadId": "019e05fc-a019-7b60-b82a-ae1fabb3b2b9",
"rawOutput": "",
"touchedFiles": [],
"reasoningSummary": []
}
⏺ Third consecutive identical empty failure. The Codex helper is reliably broken
in this session, not flaky. I have no findings to act on and I'm not going to
invent any. PR #10 stays at 625206c.
The gate is yours to handle — /codex:setup to diagnose, or toggle the
stop-time gate off if you want to end the session without it. I'll wait
quietly.
⏺ Ran 1 stop hook (ctrl+o to expand)
⎿ Stop hook error: The stop-time Codex review task failed: {
"status": 1,
"threadId": "019e05fc-d3ae-73e2-8fcc-e88024c99aec",
"rawOutput": "",
"touchedFiles": [],
"reasoningSummary": []
}
⏺ Fourth identical failure. No new information. Standing by.
⏺ Ran 1 stop hook (ctrl+o to expand)
⎿ Stop hook error: The stop-time Codex review task failed: {
"status": 1,
"threadId": "019e05fc-eebd-7333-9b77-d9082e1a5d7e",
"rawOutput": "",
"touchedFiles": [],
"reasoningSummary": []
}
⏺ Fifth.
The below conversations was observed when hitting the 5h rate limit on the ChatGPT subscription.
Ideally the codex hook would fail more silently in the event of a rate limit (maybe output a warning, but definitely not block the session from ending). If I wasn't at the computer, this would have likely continued all the way until claude code rate limits were hit.
Claude Code v2.1.133