Conversation
|
Will check again soon but yes it worked fine for me |
|
Amazing - works pretty awesome! What do you think about showing the masking while dragging the slider and not just when holding down ALT? I'm unsure how many people will realize they have to press ALT. What I noticed is that the threshold and the functionality in general is pretty inconsistent across RAW resolutions, preview resolutions and jpeg itself. Do you have a fix for this in mind? Thanks a lot for your work!! :) |
|
Yeah you are right. I just thought I'll keep it consistent from LR, but I solely use that slider there while pressing alt. I could try to normalize the sharpening threshold by image resolution so the mask stays consistent whether you’re looking at a low-res preview or full-res file. |
|
Hi @d1anarene Thanks again for the update. The UX improvement with always showing the mask while dragging works good. But I’m still noticing that the actual sharpening being applied doesn’t fully match what I’m seeing in the black/white mask preview. The mask preview looks correct, but the final sharpened result seems to affect different areas. I think this might be related to how the threshold behaves across different resolutions. If the Canny/edge detection for the preview mask is being calculated on a downscaled preview image, that could explain the mismatch when the sharpening is later applied to the full-resolution RAW. Differences in scaling, interpolation, or gradient strength between resolutions might be shifting the effective threshold. Maybe we need to either:
Could you take another look at how the preview mask and the final sharpening mask are derived relative to image resolution? Thanks a lot and have a great evening, |
|
Is this ready for another review? |

Lightroom Style sharpening mask slider
Applied area can be seen when dragging while pressing "Alt"
Requested in #690